CocoCay Finally has Competition: Is NCL's New Great Stirrup Cay Better?

899 views · 33 likes · 21 comments · Jun 4, 2026 · 19:33 · Long
Open on YouTube

Is Norwegian Cruise Line's Great Stirrup Cay finally a true competitor to Royal Caribbean's CocoCay? In this video, we compare two of the most popular cruise line private islands in the Bahamas: Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay and Norwegian Cruise Line's Great Stirrup Cay. After visiting both islands, we're breaking down the beaches, pools, food, drinks, crowds, activities, water parks, cabanas, and overall experience to help you decide which destination is right for your next cruise vacation. We'll cover: First Impressions and Arrival Experience Beach Quality and Seating Oasis Lagoon vs Great Stirrup Cay's New Pool Food Options and Included the Best Bite! Drink Packages and Bar Availability Water Parks and Activities Adult-Only Areas and Premium Experiences Cabanas, Villas, and Beach Clubs For years, CocoCay has been considered the gold standard of cruise line private islands. But with Norwegian investing heavily in Great Stirrup Cay, adding a new pier, massive pool, upgraded facilities, and an upcoming water park, is CocoCay still the king of the cruise industry? Whether you're sailing on Royal Caribbean, Norwegian Cruise Line, Icon of the Seas, Utopia of the Seas, Wonder of the Seas, Norwegian Getaway, Norwegian Aqua, or another ship visiting these destinations, this comparison will help you decide which island experience fits your travel style. Have you visited CocoCay or Great Stirrup Cay? Let us know your favorite in the comments! We are Crystal and Marshall, a 50+ couple from Florida (by way of Maine) who love to cruise and take you with us on our adventures. We show you all of our ships, trips, and tips while cruising. Please subscribe and follow our journey. Thank you for joining & supporting our channel. Thanks for supporting our channel. You can check out our website at https://cruisingwithcrystalandmarshall.com

#perfect day at cococay#CocoCay#Great Stirrup Cay#CocoCay vs Great Stirrup Cay#Royal Caribbean#Norwegian Cruise Line#Perfect Day at CocoCay#Great Stirrup Cay review#cruise private islands#cruise comparison#Bahamas cruise#Royal Caribbean CocoCay#NCL Great Stirrup Cay#CocoCay review#Great Stirrup Cay 2026#cruise tips#cruise vacation#cruise vlog#cruise travel#Norwegian Getaway#Icon of the Seas#cruise island comparison#Cruising with Crystal and Marshall

Analytics

We use Google Analytics to count visits and see which pages are popular. It sets cookies and sends your IP address and browsing on this site to Google. You can turn it off at any time.